Is a Viscous Friction Damper Governed by Speed or Slip?

Update:18 Nov

A search for a Viscous Friction Damper lands on two different devices that share one phrase. A fluid viscous damper pushes silicone oil through small orifices, and the force it produces depends on how fast the piston moves. A friction damper clamps steel plates together with bolts and slides at a set load, and the force it produces depends on the clamping and not on speed. Engineers choose a Viscous Friction Damper of one kind or the other by asking which quantity, velocity or slip load, suits the structure.

Two Laws, Two Hysteresis Loops

A fluid viscous damper follows F = C·vᵅ. The force F rises with velocity v, C is the damping coefficient and α is an exponent that is typically set between about 0.3 and 1. With α = 1 the damper is linear, and doubling the velocity doubles the force. With α = 0.5 the same doubling raises the force by only about 41 percent, because 2 to the power 0.5 is 1.41. That is why nonlinear Viscous Friction Dampers of the fluid type are specified where peak force needs a ceiling.

A friction damper, the other half of the Viscous Friction Damper search term, follows a different rule. The force is the friction coefficient times the clamping force on the interfaces, summed over the interfaces, and it stays about constant once sliding starts. Speed hardly enters.

The two also differ in stiffness. Before it slips, a friction damper adds stiffness to the frame and shortens its period, whereas a linear fluid damper adds almost none, since its force is zero at the turning point of the motion. A Viscous Friction Damper of either kind therefore changes the response of the structure in a different way, and the analysis model carries both effects.

Behaviour

Fluid viscous damper

Friction damper

Force depends on

Velocity

Clamping force and friction coefficient

Hysteresis loop

Ellipse for a linear damper

Close to a rectangle

Below the activation point

Acts at any movement

Locked, adds stiffness

Medium

Silicone oil

Steel plates and friction material

What the Phase Difference Does to the Frame

The viscous force is out of phase with the displacement. If a floor moves as x = X sin ωt, its velocity follows cos ωt, so a linear damper delivers its largest force when the floor passes through the centre position and almost none at the turning point. The elastic force in the columns peaks at the turning point instead, so the two forces do not arrive together. This is the main reason a Fluid Viscous Damper can remove energy from a structure without adding its full peak force to the column forces at max drift.

A friction damper behaves the other way round. Its force is a plateau that reaches the slip load as soon as sliding begins and holds it across the stroke, so it caps the force the brace can deliver and the loop area is large for the displacement used.

Slip Load Is a Design Number

In a Viscous Friction Damper of the friction kind, the plates are clamped by high-strength bolts through slotted holes. The slip load is set large enough that the damper stays locked under wind and service loads, and it slips only when a larger earthquake pushes the brace beyond that value.

4219

Because slip load equals friction coefficient times clamping force, two things are controlled together: the bolt preload and the friction material. A test on the friction material alone tells half of the story, so bolt torque is checked in the same test.

Choosing by What the Structure Needs

Specifying a Viscous Friction Damper by name leaves the type open, so a drawing states the device kind, the force law, the stroke and the max force.

A Fluid Viscous Damper suits structures where damping is wanted across a wide range of movement, including small ones, since it responds to velocity from the smallest movement. The silicone oil inside also changes viscosity less with temperature than many hydraulic oils, so the force stays closer to its design value across seasons.

A friction device suits structures where a defined force limit and a high energy loss per cycle are wanted, and where the brace can stay silent under wind. Zhejiang Earthquake Prevention Technology makes both fluid viscous and friction dampers, together with the isolation bearings used alongside them.

Comparative studies on steel buildings treat the damping coefficient of the fluid device and the slip load of the friction device as the two design variables, and both kinds of Viscous Friction Damper brought acceleration and displacement down in the frames studied.

HOT PRODCUTS

  • LRB( lead rubber bearing) :LRB-Ⅰ、LRB-Ⅱ

    LRB( lead rubber bearing) :LRB-Ⅰ、LRB-Ⅱ

  • LNR(linear rubber bearing):LNR-Ⅰ、LNR-Ⅱ

    LNR(linear rubber bearing):LNR-Ⅰ、LNR-Ⅱ

  • Building Vibration Isolation Rubber Bearings

    Building Vibration Isolation Rubber Bearings

  • Elastic Sliding Bearing (ESB)

    Elastic Sliding Bearing (ESB)

  • HDR ( high damping rubber)

    HDR ( high damping rubber)

  • Rubber bearing for stair interval earthquake collapse

    Rubber bearing for stair interval earthquake collapse

  • Friction pendulum isolation bearing

    Friction pendulum isolation bearing

  • Metal damper

    Metal damper

  • BRB(buckling restrained brace)

    BRB(buckling restrained brace)

  • Viscous fluid damper

    Viscous fluid damper

  • Viscoleastic damper

    Viscoleastic damper

  • Friction damper

    Friction damper